One of these characters is going to get drilled. And that character’s name is Mario.

It’s time for Part 2 of Super Mario Galaxy 2. Ranked 17th on our list of the best games of all-time, our dramatic re-enactment of “Plumbers in Space” is the newest Broadway hit that’s sweeping the nation.

Chris and Shaun are taking on the entire game in this playthrough. That’s right — all the way through every green star. Have a game you want to see us suffer through play next? Let us know in the comments or by sending us an email. Now that this is a series, we’ve created its own page, which you can see here. It’ll list all the games we’ve done so far and what might be coming next.

It’s time to make space in Mario’s heart for a new lover. Game on.